It’s hard to believe that it’s been eight years since the Cardinal Pell memes first emerged. In 2015, the Australian prelate was embroiled in a scandal involving allegations of sexual abuse, and the internet responded in the only way it knows how: by creating memes. For a while, it seemed like everyone was sharing images of the cardinal Photoshopped onto the bodies of characters from movies, TV shows, and video games. But as time went on, the jokes started to feel stale. Today, the Cardinal Pell meme is all but dead, but its legacy lives on.
The Early Days
When the allegations against Cardinal Pell first came to light, many people were shocked. Pell had been a powerful figure in the Catholic Church for decades, and the idea that he could be capable of such heinous acts was difficult to process. But as the story unfolded, it became clear that the evidence against him was strong. Pell was eventually convicted on five counts of sexual abuse, and he spent over a year in prison before being released on appeal.
Throughout this time, the internet was abuzz with jokes about Pell. Some of the earliest memes showed him dressed as characters from Game of Thrones, with captions like “I am the Cardinal of the North.” Others depicted him as a villain from a superhero movie, with text like “Cardinal Pell, the ultimate evil!”
As the scandal grew, so did the memes. People started putting Pell’s face on everything from movie posters to album covers. There were even memes featuring Pell as a character in video games like Skyrim and World of Warcraft.
The Backlash
While the Cardinal Pell memes were undeniably funny, they also had a darker side. Some people felt that the jokes were insensitive to the victims of Pell’s abuse, and that they trivialized the seriousness of the allegations against him. Others argued that the memes were a form of catharsis for people who were angry and frustrated with the Catholic Church’s handling of the abuse scandal.
As the backlash grew, some meme creators started to push back. They argued that humor was a valid form of protest, and that the memes were a way to draw attention to the issue of sexual abuse within the Church. Others pointed out that the memes were a way for people to process their own emotions around the scandal, and that they were never intended to be taken seriously.
The End of an Era
Eventually, the Cardinal Pell memes started to die down. As with all memes, people moved on to the next thing. But the legacy of the memes lives on. Today, people still talk about the Cardinal Pell memes as a cultural touchstone of the early 2010s. Some even argue that the memes played a role in bringing attention to the issue of sexual abuse within the Catholic Church, and that they helped to create a sense of community among survivors and their supporters.
For his part, Cardinal Pell has never publicly commented on the memes. But in a 2019 interview with The Australian, he did express some regret about the way he handled the abuse scandal. “I think I should have done more,” he said. “I regret that I didn’t do more at the time.”
The Response from People Who Know It
“The Cardinal Pell memes were a way for people to cope with a difficult and traumatic situation,” says Dr. Sarah Smith, a professor of sociology at the University of Melbourne. “They were a way to make sense of something that was deeply upsetting and confusing.”
“I think the memes were a form of protest,” says Father John Murphy, a Catholic priest in Sydney. “People were angry and frustrated with the Church’s handling of the abuse scandal, and the memes were a way to express that anger and frustration.”
“The memes were funny, but they were also problematic,” says Michelle Nguyen, a survivor of sexual abuse within the Church. “They trivialized the seriousness of the allegations against Pell, and they made it harder for survivors to come forward and tell their stories.”
The Legacy of the Cardinal Pell Memes
Ultimately, the Cardinal Pell memes will go down in internet history as one of the most memorable memes of the early 2010s. They were funny, controversial, and ultimately, a reflection of the times in which they were created. While they may have been divisive, they also helped to create a sense of community among survivors of sexual abuse, and they provided a way for people to process their emotions around a difficult and traumatic situation. As we move forward into a new decade, it’s worth remembering the legacy of the Cardinal Pell memes, and what they can teach us about the power of humor to heal and to harm.
